Do you know if the high protein diet is dangerous? What exactly is the high protein diet? And what kind of damage is it associated with it, if any? Let’s dig deeper into the subject.
Protein is a vital macronutrient essential for the growth, repair, and maintenance of all bodily tissues, including muscles. It plays a crucial role in nutrition as it is made up of amino acids, the building blocks for many structures in the body, not just muscle. These amino acids are necessary for vital processes such as the synthesis of hormones and enzymes, and the maintenance of immune function. Adequate protein intake is essential for overall health, helping to repair cells and create new ones.
In the context of muscle building, protein is particularly important as it provides the necessary components to repair and build muscle tissue after exercise. When muscles are stressed during exercise, especially during strength and resistance training, small tears occur in the muscle fibers. Protein facilitates the repair of these microtears, which, over time, leads to an increase in muscle size and strength. This process, known as muscle protein synthesis, is why athletes and individuals looking to build muscle focus on consuming adequate amounts of high-quality protein in their diet.
The information for this article is based on a video shared on YouTube with Richie Kirwan explaining all he knows about a high-protein diet.
Richie Kirwan is a nutritionist and a figure in the fitness and health industry, known for his expertise in sports nutrition and his efforts to provide evidence-based nutritional advice. Kirwan often contribute significantly to the scientific community through client consultations, writing, speaking engagements, and online content creation. The video you are about to see was shared on the MyProtein YouTube channel.
Is the High Protein Diet Dangerous?
Richie Kirwan discusses the variances in protein intake recommendations and actual consumption patterns, especially among those in fitness and bodybuilding circles.
The Spectrum of Protein Intake
Kirwan elucidates, “For building muscle, the usual recommended protein intake is around 1.6 to 2.2 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight per day.” This recommendation contrasts starkly with the actual intakes observed in some fitness enthusiasts and bodybuilders, who may consume upwards of 3.7 grams per kilogram per day. Kirwan adds, “That’s not to say you need that much, but those high amounts of protein intake are pretty regularly seen in studies, just to give you an idea.” This statement reflects the broad spectrum of protein consumption, highlighting a significant gap between general guidelines and the practices of individuals aiming for muscle hypertrophy.
How to Calculate Macros and Calories
Contextualizing the UK’s Recommendations
When juxtaposed with the UK’s standard of 0.79 grams per kilogram, the disparity becomes even more pronounced. Kirwan notes, “The current UK recommendation…works out at a total of 53 grams per day for an average 70-kilogram person. Some people on a high protein diet get that much in a single meal.” This comparison not only underscores the variance in protein intake across different populations but also prompts a reevaluation of what constitutes ‘high’ protein intake within diverse dietary contexts.
Read Also: 9 Foods You Should Never Eat Before a Workout
Kidney Conundrum: Protein’s Impact on Renal Function
Kirwan explains the underlying biological processes, stating, “When we eat protein, the excess needs to be processed and filtered by our kidneys, which is exactly what the kidneys are supposed to do.” He clarifies that the increased workload on the kidneys due to higher protein intake is a natural physiological response, not inherently detrimental in healthy individuals.
Differentiating Between Populations
Highlighting the importance of distinguishing between different population groups, Kirwan mentions, “The research that says that this could be a bad thing is often carried out in people who already have some form of kidney disease or other illnesses.” This distinction is crucial, as it separates the effects of high protein intake on healthy individuals versus those with pre-existing renal conditions. Kirwan further elaborates, “If your kidneys are healthy, a high protein diet is not a problem. However, if someone already has kidney problems, they should keep an eye on their protein intake and diet in general.”
7 Foods That Cause Inflammation – Keep Away From These
Scientific Insights: Delving Deeper into Protein and Kidney Health
Kirwan references a significant investigation involving over 1,500 women tracked for 11 years, which serves as a cornerstone in understanding protein’s impact on kidneys. “At the end of that study, there was no association between protein and changes in kidney function in women who had healthy kidney function at the start,” Kirwan notes. This revelation underscores a crucial distinction: the baseline health of one’s kidneys plays a pivotal role in how protein intake influences renal function.
High Protein Intake in Healthy Individuals: A Closer Look
Kirwan delves into studies that specifically examine the effects of high protein diets on individuals with no pre-existing kidney conditions. One such study by Dr Jose Antonio is highlighted, where participants consumed a very high protein diet of up to 3.4 grams per kilogram per day. Kirwan elaborates, “At the end of the protocol, there were no changes in kidney function in either group, no changes at all.” This finding is instrumental in dispelling the myth that high protein intake inherently harms kidney health in healthy individuals.
Read More: 10 Protein-Packed Foods You Had No Idea About
The Year-Long Crossover Study: A Comprehensive Examination
Perhaps one of the most telling pieces of evidence comes from a year-long crossover study that Kirwan discusses, where young men alternated between normal and high protein intakes. “After a diet of between 2.5 and 3.3 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight per day for a whole year, there were no negative effects on kidney health,” Kirwan states. This study not only reinforces the safety of high protein diets but also showcases the resilience of healthy kidneys when subjected to increased protein loads over an extended period.
Implications for Athletes and Bodybuilders
The context of these studies is particularly relevant for athletes and bodybuilders, who often consume protein well above the average intake. Kirwan points out, “For athletes and people trying to put on muscle, that’s a pretty normal protein intake, and it’s really good to know that it’s safe.” This statement is a testament to the robustness of the human body and its ability to handle varying nutrient demands, especially in the context of heightened physical activity and muscle synthesis requirements.
15 Foods to Speed Up Muscle Growth
The discourse surrounding protein and kidney health is nuanced, with a clear delineation based on individual health status. For those with robust kidney function, embracing a high-protein diet appears to be safe and devoid of the feared renal repercussions. However, it’s paramount to approach dietary choices with a lens of balance and moderation, ensuring that the quest for protein doesn’t overshadow the spectrum of nutritional needs essential for optimal health.
In light of the evidence, it’s time to revisit our dietary blueprints, possibly reshaping them with a newfound understanding of protein’s role and its compatibility with kidney health. Whether you’re an athlete, a fitness enthusiast, or simply someone aiming for nutritional optimisation, it seems the protein path, when trodden with awareness and balance, is one less fraught with renal risk than previously perceived.
Watch the video below for more information regarding the high protein diet as explained by Richie Kirwan.
Read Also: 5 “Healthy Foods” Filled with Sugar You Should Avoid
