Chilling Truths: Debunking Cold Water Immersion Myths in Fitness

| Apr 25, 2024 / 4 min read

You probably heard of the awesome benefits of cold water immersion. However, not all is rainbows and butterflies. There is a lot still to know about it and, it turns out, it is not a magic pill you can take to improve your life overall. Check out some cold water immersion myths in fitness in the paragraphs below.

In the world of fitness and wellness, the allure of extreme measures for quick results can sometimes overshadow the importance of basic, sustained efforts and the facts. This is particularly true in the case of cold water immersion and its purported benefits on fat loss and metabolic rate enhancement. Your humorous and critical take on the exaggerated claims about cold water immersion highlights a larger issue in fitness culture: the search for a magic bullet.

Rich Froning recovers in his cold plunge

Cold water immersion, also known as ice baths or cold water therapy, has been gaining popularity, especially among athletes, for its benefits such as reducing muscle soreness and inflammation after intense physical activity. However, the claims that sitting in cold water can drastically increase metabolism and testosterone levels, or dramatically burn calories, deserve scrutiny. And that is what Dr Layne Norton did in a recent video.

Dr Layne Norton is a scientist, pro-natural bodybuilder, raw elite powerlifter, and physique coach, among other things. He received his BS in Biochemistry, and his PhD in Nutritional Sciences. Besides being a coach, he also commands his YouTube channel in which he talks about science and fitness intertwined, sometimes breaking down scientific studies that come out so people can make better informed decisions in their fitness journey.

Related: What Happens to your Body after 30 Days of Cold Showers?

Let’s take a deep dive into cold water immersion myths in fitness.

Debunking Cold Water Immersion Myths in Fitness

  1. Caloric Burn and Metabolism: The idea that cold water immersion significantly increases calorie burn or metabolism isn’t supported by substantial scientific evidence. While exposure to cold can increase energy expenditure because the body has to work harder to maintain its core temperature, the effects are often not as dramatic as claimed. The numbers cited in various enthusiastic endorsements (like burning 1,600 calories in 3 minutes) are scientifically implausible and greatly exaggerated.
  2. Testosterone Levels: Similarly, claims about massive increases in testosterone levels due to cold water baths are not supported by robust scientific data. While some studies suggest mild benefits of cold exposure for hormone modulation, the increase is nowhere near the 700% touted by some proponents.
  3. Fat Loss: Regular cold water immersion might help marginally with fat loss as part of a broader program of diet and exercise, but it is not a standalone fat loss solution. The mechanism proposed is the activation of brown fat, which uses white fat as fuel to generate heat. However, effective and significant fat loss primarily results from sustained caloric deficit and not from short, infrequent bouts of cold exposure.
  4. Health Risks: It’s also worth mentioning that cold water immersion is not safe for everyone. It can pose health risks, including hypothermia, to individuals not accustomed to extreme cold, and it is particularly risky for those with cardiovascular conditions.
Rich Froning recovers in Cold Plunge 2

Conclusion

While cold water immersion may have its place as a recovery tool for athletes, its effects on metabolism, fat loss, and testosterone levels are often overstated without adequate scientific backing. As with any fitness trend, it’s important to approach it with a critical eye and realistic expectations. Relying on cold water immersion as a primary method for fat loss or metabolic enhancement is not advisable.

In this case, skepticism is well-founded, and it serves as a reminder that in fitness, as in many areas of life, there are rarely shortcuts to achieving substantial results. The best approach is always a balanced diet, regular exercise, and realistic, sustainable health practices.

Watch the video below from Layne Norton to understand better the myths of cold water immersion.

Read Also: The 5 Worst Pieces of Advice for a Long Life (You Should Never Listen To)

image sources

Tags:
cold plunge ice bath layne norton myths

RECOMMENDED ARTICLES