Pre-Exhaustion and Drop Sets: Are They Worth It?

What’s up, fitness enthusiasts! Ready to dive deep into some muscle-building science? If you’re someone who’s been hitting the gym but wondering whether intensity techniques can help you build more muscle, you’re in the right place. Let’s break down what research has to say about intensity techniques like pre-exhaustion and drop sets and whether they’re worth adding to your routine.

First, let’s talk about what these techniques are, why people use them, and what a recent human randomized control trial reveals about their actual effectiveness. Hang tight, because we’re diving into the muscle-building deep end!

The information for this article is largely based on the expertise from Dr Layne Norton, a scientist, pro natural bodybuilder, raw elite powerlifter, and physique coach, among other things. He received his BS in Biochemistry, and his PhD in Nutritional Sciences. Besides being a coach, he also commands his YouTube channel in which he talks about science and fitness intertwined, sometimes breaking down scientific studies that come out so people can make better-informed decisions in their fitness journey.

What Are Intensity Techniques?

• Pre-Exhaustion: This involves doing an isolation exercise before a compound exercise. For example, instead of jumping straight into bench presses, you’d start with chest flys to pre-exhaust the chest muscles. The idea is to fatigue the primary muscles earlier, leading to more targeted growth.
• Drop Sets: A drop set means starting with a heavy load, going until failure, then reducing the weight and continuing. The idea here is to push your muscles beyond their typical limits by immediately lowering the weight and going until you’re spent.

So, do these methods really build more muscle compared to traditional straight sets? A recent study dived into just that.

The Study Breakdown: What Did the Research Look Like?

Let’s talk numbers: 66 healthy, recreationally trained young men were split into three groups:

1. Traditional training (standard sets with consistent weight)
2. Pre-exhaustion (starting with isolation exercises before compound ones)
3. Drop sets (reducing the load after reaching failure)

Each group followed their respective routines twice weekly for six weeks. Exercises included leg presses and leg extensions, with the groups performing different intensity techniques but sticking to the same exercises. Measurements were taken for strength, hypertrophy, and recovery, among other factors.

You can check out the entire study at this link.

What Did They Find?

Here’s the kicker: All three groups had similar results. Whether it was traditional sets, pre-exhaustion, or drop sets, all participants showed muscle growth and strength improvement with no significant differences between the groups. Essentially, the number of hard sets and proximity to failure seemed to be more important than the type of intensity technique used.

This finding suggests that these advanced techniques might not be magic bullets for muscle growth—especially if you’re just focusing on getting in enough hard work and volume.

The Science Behind Pre-Exhaustion

• How it works: Typically, compound exercises (like bench presses or squats) involve multiple muscles. If smaller muscles fatigue first (e.g., your triceps in a bench press), the main muscle (like the chest) might not reach full exhaustion. Pre-exhaustion isolates the larger muscle first, theoretically allowing for more targeted work when you hit the compound exercise next.
• Research results: Despite the clever logic behind pre-exhaustion, the trial showed no significant advantage in terms of muscle growth over traditional training. It might feel like your muscles are working harder, but in reality, it’s the total volume of hard sets and effort that seems to count more.

The Science Behind Drop Sets

• How it works: When you finish a set and can’t push the same weight any further, your muscles are usually exhausted for that specific load—but they still have more to give at a lighter weight. Drop sets take advantage of this by allowing you to continue the set at reduced loads, squeezing out more muscle fatigue.
• Research results: In the study, the drop set group didn’t see more muscle growth than the other groups, even though they performed the same exercises to failure at a reduced load after reaching their peak. Like pre-exhaustion, drop sets aren’t necessarily a superior technique but can be useful if you’re short on time and want to get more work done in fewer sets.

Related: The Ultimate Guide to Drop Sets

Limitations and Practical Applications

Now, you might be wondering: Does that mean intensity techniques are a waste of time? Not exactly. While this study suggests that intensity techniques might not be superior, they still have their place in a well-rounded training routine.

Pre-Exhaustion

• When to use it: If you’re someone who struggles with joint pain or injuries during heavy compound exercises, pre-exhaustion can be a great workaround. By fatiguing your main muscles earlier, you may not need as much weight to stimulate growth, reducing strain on your joints.

Drop Sets

• When to use it: If you’re short on time, drop sets can help pack in more volume without needing extra sets. They’re a fantastic option for people who want to densify their workouts—getting more done in less time without skipping on the burn.

What Really Matters? Hard Sets and Volume

The study makes it clear: It’s not about which fancy technique you’re using. The real key to muscle growth is the number of hard sets you do, your proximity to failure, and overall volume. Whether you’re using traditional methods or throwing in some intensity techniques, what’s most important is that you’re pushing yourself hard enough consistently over time.

As the research noted, it’s possible that more advanced lifters might see some differences with these techniques, but for the average gym-goer, it’s all about hitting the right level of intensity and getting enough volume.

Key Takeaways

• Intensity techniques aren’t inherently superior: Pre-exhaustion and drop sets aren’t going to magically grow your muscles faster than traditional sets.
• Volume is king: The number of hard sets and how close you get to failure are more critical than the method itself.
• Use techniques based on your needs: Pre-exhaustion is great if you have joint pain, and drop sets are perfect for getting in more volume when you’re short on time.

Conclusion: How Should You Train?

Ultimately, if you’re someone who’s trying to build muscle, the best advice is to stick to the basics, but don’t be afraid to mix it up. Whether it’s traditional sets, pre-exhaustion, or drop sets, the key is hitting enough hard sets and getting close enough to failure. And remember, just because intensity techniques aren’t superior doesn’t mean they don’t have a place in your routine.

So next time you’re in the gym, feel free to experiment with pre-exhaustion or drop sets, but know that what really matters is pushing your muscles to work hard and doing it often.

There you go! Hopefully, this clears up whether or not intensity techniques are worth adding to your muscle-building plan. Happy lifting, and remember: it’s all about consistency and effort!

The Impact of Resistance Training on Depression and Anxiety, New Research